How the 90-9-1 participation ratio changes inside organizations

Man with laptop and blueprintsHoward Lenos writes about the 90-9-1 rule as a benchmark for assessing participation in online communities. Here’s a comment I left on his post that looks at how the rule changes inside organizations:

One point about the 90-9-1 rule that I see in my consulting work inside organizations: the ratio is quite different. The ratio trends toward 60% knowledge champions (people who contribute most often), so the focus needs to be on the 40% that contribute occasionally or only passively read content.

There’s work to be done here, but the existing structure in organizations – unlike online communities on the open web – helps influence people to become more active contributors. For instance, if everyone on your team is using the wiki for meeting agendas & minutes, and you’re the lone holdout, the others will encourage you to use the wiki too. They’ll do it b/c they don’t want that one email they have to deal with from you when everyone else is better connected thanks to the wiki.

The key to success is how they do it – if they’re hard on you for being slow to switch, you might dig your heels in an refuse to succumb. On the other hand, if they show you how to contribute, and give you some direct support, that may be all you needed to get started in the first place.

6 Comments

  1. I think the ratio is quite different externally on the web too, based on findings from Jeremiah Owyang at Forrester and stats like this: http://blogs.forrester.com/charleneli/2007/04/forresters_new_.html from Groundswell… the 1% is more like 15+ now at least…

Leave a Comment

Books
  • "Highly recommended."
  • "Important and insightful."
  • "Impressive. Read it."
  • Order from Amazon.com
  • Wikipatterns book: a practical guide to improving productivity and collaboration in your organization Using Wiki in Education wiki book

    random image

    Photos
    Click the photo above, or choose a photo essay
    Airbus FactoryBarcelona & MadridBritish Museum
    IstanbulPortoSydneyVancouverYosemite




    Work
    Future Changes is the online home of Stewart Mader, an experienced content strategist and project manager, dynamic speaker to corporate audiences and conferences, and author of two books. He has helped organizations around the world, including Booz Allen Hamilton, Brown University, ICANN, MARS, SAP, and The World Bank develop content strategies and build products that increase information value, collaboration, and employee & customer engagement.

    Future Changes, founded in October 2005, has been cited by CIO Magazine, Fast Company, InformationWeek, InfoWorld, The Guardian, The New York Times, and The New Yorker.

    View Work Samples and Work with Stewart