Wikipedia: It’s Free, but It’s Also Fallible – ?

Just read this article by David Nguyen of the Sacramento Bee: Wikipedia: It’s Free, but It’s Also Fallible and I think it’s very telling. For instance, he chose to ask a person who has never used Wikipedia to comment on it for this article – bad move. This is what fuels stereotypes and misconceptions about new tools. Reading further in the article, it seems the safe answer people default to is that “wikipedia is a nice starting point, but shouldn’t be accepted as a reference” or “make sure your students check the accuracy of what they find in wikipedia by comparing it to other sources”.

I have two questions about those statements:
1. If we’re so afraid of how wikipedia will be used in schools, doesn’t that make it look like teachers haven’t taught students how to be good researchers until now?
2. Shouldn’t someone mention that the other sources you might check wikipedia against aren’t necessarily more accurate?
I think I just did.

No Comments

Leave a Comment

Books
  • "Highly recommended."
  • "Important and insightful."
  • "Impressive. Read it."
  • Order from Amazon.com
  • Wikipatterns book: a practical guide to improving productivity and collaboration in your organization Using Wiki in Education wiki book

    random image

    Photos
    Click the photo above, or choose a photo essay
    Airbus FactoryBarcelona & MadridBritish Museum
    IstanbulPortoSydneyVancouverYosemite




    Work
    Future Changes is the online home of Stewart Mader, an experienced content strategist and project manager, dynamic speaker to corporate audiences and conferences, and author of two books. He has helped organizations around the world, including Booz Allen Hamilton, Brown University, ICANN, MARS, SAP, and The World Bank develop content strategies and build products that increase information value, collaboration, and employee & customer engagement.

    Future Changes, founded in October 2005, has been cited by CIO Magazine, Fast Company, InformationWeek, InfoWorld, The Guardian, The New York Times, and The New Yorker.

    View Work Samples and Work with Stewart